When Neurodivergent Children Struggle With Learning, Are We Asking the Right Questions?

Written by:

What happens when a child consistently resists learning? When schoolwork becomes a battle, everyday expectations lead to distress, or a child seems unable or unwilling to engage with what is being asked of them?

It’s easy to focus on the behaviour we can see. We might describe a child as defiant, unmotivated, difficult or unwilling to cooperate. We might assume they need more structure, more practice or firmer expectations.

But what if we’re asking the wrong question?

What if, instead of asking why a child won’t do something, we started asking what is making it difficult for them to do it?

This is one of the ideas I explored in my recent conversation with Afsaneh Moradian, founder of MLC Homeschool Coaching and host of the Neurodiverse Homeschooling Summit. Afsaneh has decades of experience in education, curriculum writing and teacher training, alongside her own experience as a neurodivergent person and homeschooling parent.

Our conversation explored homeschooling, neurodivergent children, education systems and the importance of understanding what sits underneath a child’s resistance to learning.

And although homeschooling was a big part of our discussion, I think the ideas extend well beyond homeschooling. They are relevant to parents, teachers and anyone working with children.


Resistance is a symptom, not the cause

One of the things Afsaneh said during our conversation really stood out to me: “Resistance it’s the symptom. It’s not the cause in and of itself.” This is such an important distinction.

When a child resists an activity, refuses to complete an assignment or becomes distressed by an everyday expectation, our first response is often to focus on getting them to comply. But resistance may be communicating that something isn’t right.

Perhaps the task is too difficult for their current developmental abilities. Perhaps the instructions aren’t clear. Perhaps the activity is repetitive, uninteresting or doesn’t feel meaningful. Perhaps the environment is overwhelming, or the child is already exhausted from trying to manage the demands of the day. There may be many reasons a child struggles to engage.

If we focus only on the behaviour, we risk missing the information it is giving us. Afsaneh explained that repeatedly trying to make a child do something without understanding the underlying difficulty can lead to even greater distress. Instead, we need to look at what is happening around the child and consider what might need to change.

This doesn’t mean removing every expectation or assuming children should never experience challenges. It means understanding the reason for the difficulty before deciding how to respond.


Not every child learns in the same way

Education often comes with an expectation that children will follow a particular sequence, complete particular tasks and demonstrate their learning in particular ways. Curricula and learning goals can be useful, but problems arise when we assume there is only one way to reach them.

Afsaneh spoke about how even homeschooling families can become caught up in curriculum expectations. Parents might purchase a programme, follow its instructions and expect their child to work through it in a particular way. But if the approach doesn’t meet the child’s developmental or learning needs, it may quickly become a source of frustration.

The same issue exists in traditional education settings. A task might have a worthwhile learning intention, but that doesn’t mean every child needs to complete it in exactly the same way.

Some children need movement. Some need more time. Some need visual information, practical experiences or opportunities to explore a concept through their interests. Others may need a different level of challenge or a change in how information is presented.

The important question is not simply whether a child can complete the task as it has been designed. It’s whether the task and the learning environment are allowing that child to engage and demonstrate what they know.


Meaningful learning matters

We also discussed the importance of making learning meaningful, purposeful and engaging. Afsaneh explained that neurodivergent children can find learning particularly difficult when activities feel tedious, boring or arbitrary.

This made me think about how often we focus on the completion of an activity rather than the learning taking place. Are we measuring whether a child has followed the instructions, or are we looking at what they have understood? Are we prioritising a particular worksheet or output, or are we considering the knowledge, creativity and problem-solving that might be happening in a completely different way?

Learning doesn’t always look neat or predictable. It can be messy, creative, exploratory and different for every child. Afsaneh also talked about the importance of moving beyond memorisation and comprehension towards applying knowledge and skills in new situations. That is a valuable reminder that learning is about much more than producing the expected answer.


What if traditional school isn’t the right fit?

An important part of our conversation was the reality that homeschooling isn’t an option for every family. There are many reasons parents may not be able to homeschool, even when they feel their child is struggling in a traditional school environment.

We discussed the challenges of finding appropriate accommodations and the differences that can exist between individual teachers, schools and education systems.

Afsaneh highlighted how often the responsibility is placed on the child to change, rather than on the environment to become more accessible. A child may be described as lazy, behind, unmotivated or unable to focus, when what they actually need is a different approach.

Of course, teachers are working within complex systems. Class sizes, limited resources, competing expectations and a lack of professional learning can make individualised support difficult.

But recognising those challenges doesn’t mean we should stop questioning whether the current approach is working. We need to keep asking how learning environments can better accommodate different ways of thinking, communicating, processing and engaging.

And we need to remember that homeschooling is not automatically the answer for every family. The bigger issue is ensuring children have access to education that recognises and supports their individual needs.


We shouldn’t define children by their hardest moments

Another particularly important part of our conversation was the way we interpret behaviour. Afsaneh spoke about how families can come to expect that learning will always involve meltdowns, shutdowns, distress or conflict. Over time, these experiences can become accepted as simply part of life with a neurodivergent child. But she offered an important reminder: we shouldn’t define our children by their worst behaviour.

Instead, we need to consider what is happening before, during and around those moments. What is causing the anxiety? What has changed? What might the child be finding difficult? What are we assuming, and have we actually asked them?

Afsaneh shared that even as a parent, she sometimes tries to work out what has upset her child, only to discover that the reason is something she hadn’t considered.

This is a reminder that we don’t always know what is happening for someone else, even when we love them and know them well. We need to make space for children to communicate their experiences and have agency in decisions that affect them.


Supporting the adults matters too

Something else I appreciated about this conversation was that Afsaneh didn’t focus exclusively on the child. She spoke about the importance of supporting parents and recognising that their wellbeing matters too.

When parents are exhausted, overwhelmed or constantly trying to manage difficult situations, it becomes much harder to make thoughtful decisions and create sustainable routines.

The same applies to educators. We often talk about supporting neurodivergent children, but what about the teachers and other professionals who are neurodivergent themselves? What about the adults who are trying to support children while navigating environments that may not meet their own needs?

If we want more supportive learning environments, we need to consider the adults within them as well. Support cannot be something we only talk about in relation to children.


Creating a different experience for the next generation

Towards the end of our conversation, Afsaneh said something that I think captures the heart of this discussion: “Let’s make sure kids now have what we didn’t get to have.”

She spoke about wanting children to learn in ways that help them feel confident in themselves, develop a strong sense of self-worth and understand how to identify and advocate for their own needs. That is such an important goal.

Many neurodivergent adults grew up feeling that they were the problem. They may have spent years believing they weren’t clever enough, weren’t trying hard enough or simply weren’t good at school.

I know that feeling personally. As someone who was late diagnosed AuDHD, I often reflect on my own experiences in education and how much I have had to unlearn. It has taken time to recognise that my ideas are worth sharing, that I can problem solve and that struggling within a particular environment doesn’t mean there is something wrong with me. I don’t want children growing up with the same beliefs about themselves.

We cannot remove every challenge from a child’s life, and there isn’t one approach that will work for everyone. But we can keep questioning our assumptions, listening to children and making changes to the environments and expectations we create.

Sometimes the most important question isn’t how we get a child to do something. It’s why we’re asking them to do it that way in the first place.


Listen to the conversation

In this episode of That AuDHD Teacher, I speak with Afsaneh Moradian about neurodivergent children, homeschooling, resistance to learning and creating educational experiences that work for individual learners.

We also discuss the Neurodiverse Homeschooling Summit, which brings together conversations and resources for families navigating neurodivergent learning.

Find Afsaneh and her work: MLC Homeschool Coaching

Whether you’re a parent, educator or someone reflecting on your own experiences of school, I hope this conversation encourages you to look beyond the behaviour and consider what a child might be trying to tell us.

Leave a Reply